TRANSCRIPT:
(This transcript is derived from an automated process. The video recording is authoritative.)
Jayden Beale:
I never thought I'd be likeable, so this is good for me. Yeah, so I'm just talking for a couple of minutes.
Last time I spoke here, I gave you the full rundown of the case and it's a very big human rights case, as you were aware of, 13 expert reports. It's finally going to trial. Don't want to go over all of that. Jewell just kindly asked me to do a quick update on what's been happening.
I might have mentioned this last time, last year they filed an application to dismiss a day before their evidence was due, which was their argument was that a Christian cannot rely upon the Bible as the basis for their belief. When they went to court for an oral hearing for that, the judge effectively mocked them. So it was a very terrible application to dismiss. The judge says, "That's a ridiculous argument, get out of here." But it came just before the day their evidence was due. And so we realise there's a real hesitation for them to file evidence.
I commenced these proceedings on 17th December 2021 in the Supreme Court. That's how long I've been in litigation with them. No Queenslander has ever seen the government's evidence, the reasons and the justifications relied upon for mandating pharmaceutical products on the entire general populace. Their evidence was finally due. Their reasons and justifications that evidence was due on the 17th of August 2026, just a few weeks ago.

They didn't file evidence again, and they said they need till the 2nd of August to file their evidence. I asked, "What have you been doing for the last five years?" And they said, "Well, Mr. Beale, because our attack on the Bible didn't quite work, we realised we now have to start building a case." And just so you know, violates every legal practitioner's ethics principle in the book.
You can't start a case five years later. But apparently, according to the government, on the 2nd of October 2026 will be the first time, and this isn't a brag by the way, this is about how ridiculous it is. I will be the first person to see it because I'm running the case, but everyone will see it eventually when it goes to trial. But it'll be the 2nd of October 2026 will be the first time ever a Queenslander has seen the reasons and justifications for why pharmaceutical products still in clinical trials were mass mandated onto the entire general public. Now, that's about five years later, right?
Does that sound like a Western democracy to you, that mass mandating pharmaceutical products and it takes a random, started as a junior law clerk really in Brisbane to just litigate constantly for five years just to get this evidence.
And by the way, in 2022, the Queensland Law Society and the Queensland Human Rights Commission criticised the government and asked for them to produce the reasons and evidence and justifications for the mandates. I then went to court basically that next week and said, see, here's the Queensland Law Society and here's the Queensland Human Right Commission saying, disclose to me the evidence. They never disclosed it.
And I just wanted to say one last thing about how difficult it has been to get this evidence, but it's finally coming. And that'll set the basis for the trial because they've seen my evidence. We filed all our reports. I'll finally get to see theirs.

I want to tell you just one very quick story about how difficult it has been to get this material. And I believe the government was protected by the courts in the more controversial period in 2021, 2022, protected so that they did not have to disclose this material because it'll be my submission that there really wasn't any real justification.
They probably did it for political reasons and more pernicious reasons really.
But when I first started this case in the Supreme Court before I transferred it into the anti-discrimination tribunal called QCAT, I won't go into the reasons, but when I was in the Supreme Court, they had a filing date to file this material in February 2022. That's how long I've been trying to get this.
When that date came around and Jake's sitting at the back, Jake is my high school friend, legal colleague who helped support me in my case. Jake said to me, he goes, "I bet you they're not going to file it." February came around, they didn't file it. And I said, "Why not?" We then went to a hearing and they said, "Well, because they were giving directions, a public direction, public health direction one and then two and then three and four, they split the mandates into four mandates." Well, they said, "We moved a full stop around and we changed a word in direction number one.
And now there's direction number two. It's a different direction." And I said, "Well, how's it different?" Well, we changed three words, does the exact same thing. And they said, "Well, because number one is no longer in place, there's nothing to disclose because you don't have legal standing to review direction number one because we moved this and word here and we crossed a T and put an I over there."
And I said, "That's ridiculous." And I said, "What are you going to disclose to me in relation to the next direction?" And they said, "We're just going to disclose to you a couple of documents for formality." And I said, "Well, where's all your scientific justifications and where's all the material that you relied upon?" And they said, "Well, that's with direction number one."
And this is a real story, by the way. And I said, "Well, give me that." I said, "Isn't that the genesis, the basis for the mandates?" They took me to the court of appeal on that question about whether I could get the original justifications for why all the mandates were given.
I went to the court of appeal on a hearing, which I lost, and then the reasoning was overturned in the high court three years later. And I said to the court of appeal, I said, they go, "Mr. Beale, why are you here? What do you want?" And I said, "I want the material for direction number one because that contains supposedly all the studies and scientific justification for the mandates to begin with." And they said, "Well, Mr. Beale, that mandate has been revoked." And in more legalistic language, I said, "So what?"

And by the way, I had a document from them which says, "Please refer to the material from direction number one to read this document." So it was so ridiculous. And the court of appeal said this to me, and I will finish on this point because you should all know what judges do to protect government when they feel like they need to do it.
The court of appeal said this to me led by the senior judge there at Justice at the time called Justice Morrison. And you can read this judgement online, by the way, you don't have to take my word for it. Justice Morrison said to me this, "You've got no legal standing to seek any legal remedy in relation to direction number one. Because it's revoked, in relation to direction number one, it's over, which means you are now the exact same as every other member of the community in relation to direction number one."
So what they were saying was because direction number one ended, even though you were discriminated against or you had your rights violated and limited by that direction, because it's ended, you are now no different to all your vaccinated counterparts because they're not affected by it now and you're not affected by it now.
So there's no legal standing to it. His legal reasoning was effectively this. If the government locked you in a cage for 50 years of your life, and after 50 years, you convince a lawyer maybe through the cage, "Hey, can you file a court document and seek a declaration and get me out of here?" The court of appeals argument was that if they let you out of the cage the day before, say a trial was to happen for that being locked in a cage for 50 years, there's no reason to examine whether that was lawful because you've just returned to the public and you're supposed to get a pat on the head and say, "Everything's all good."

And in that hearing with the court of appeal, I went meticulously through the law on declaratory relief and the point of legal remedy and the point of a declaration is to denounce wrongdoing by government and it's meaningful justice for people.
And his ultimate argument was if the government violates your rights for any period of time, even if it's your entire life, if just before you about to have a trial, they stop it, you have no right to seek any legal remedy unless you can prove maybe they owe you some money. But that was the reasoning of the Supreme Court of Appeal in this country, in the state.
And that's how they viewed your rights. The government can violate them for however long you want, and if they stop, that's it, you're stuffed.
Yeah, that's right. And you should all know that, that's how they thought during COVID-19 and it's a travesty and the worst legal reasoning.
And it just goes to show how indifferent and how ignorant our leaders are in terms of rights and things. I don't want to take any questions, but we'll talk after. I'll have a chat to you. When is the judiciary going to be held accountable? Yes. And I'm hopefully going to use the story of my case to go after those terrible decisions, but I hope that gives you an update on everything that's happening and 2nd of October, hopefully I'll come back and give some goss. Yeah. Anyway, thank you.





